I have been observing a very strange phenomenon for the past few months. Wherever I go, whether it’s the Metro , a mall, a park, or any public place for that matter, I find people carrying a copy of The 3 Mistakes of My Life, the latest from the best selling yuppie Indian author Chetan Bhagat. You may wonder why do I call it strange? After all reading books is by and large a healthy habit. It is, agreed, but one also has to acknowledge the fact that in a country like ours the only kind of books people (especially students) are encouraged to read are the academic kinds. Therefore you could call it a welcome change too.
Now if you have been following the critical response to the three books he’s written you would’ve observed that its largely been unfavourable. The literary critics have lambasted him left, right and center. They’ve called his writing unbelievably amateurish, his grammar elementary and his subject matter pedestrian, to say the least.
Well leaving that aside for a moment lets looks at some hard facts. He is by far India's best selling author in English. His book, Five Point Someone has achieved an unparalleled cult status among the youth. The second one, One Night@ The Call Centre is all set to be major motion picture and the third one is on the top of the popularity charts (yet again).
Seems like a paradox, doesn't it? What secret code has this IIT-D and IIM-A alumnus cracked that has changed the face of Indian writng in English forever? Although i don't claim to have THE answer, I do have some of my own reasons which might justify this trend.
The unique thing about Chetan Bhagat is that all those points on which he has been criticized have turned out to be the very reason his runaway success. From the almost prose like elementary English which everyone can understand, to the affordability of his books (each at a flat rate of Rs. 95) have contributed immensely to his success. In him the youth see an Icon who writes for them and in the kind of language they understand and not as a pretentious snot focusing on a non-descript minority. That's why they back him to the hilt.
See I am nowhere close to being a fan of his style, but then that, like the critics opinion of him, is irrelevant. He may never be as accomplished a writer as Frederick Forsyth, Jeffrey Archer,Mario Puzo,Paulo Coelho and other international favourites. Hell, his style of writing not even be as suave as many of the accomplished Indian authors in English like Amitav Ghosh, Vikram Seth, Vikram Chandra,V.S. Naipaul etc. but then he doesn't really have to worry about these comparisons because at the end public opinion is not swayed by literary snob value. Its all about what they can identify with....
Happy Reading !
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
9 comments:
Nice .. I like the way you think ..
It seems you dont want to like him (not that u hate him ) , just because all the ppl have gone mad after him.
Can't really comment on what it seems because that is a conjuncture of your imagination, but my personal affinity for his literature is not dependent on what others think of it.
Can literature really be judged by the fact that it's 'affordable' or its easy to read and understand and so sets the masses tickin'?
Personally for me good literature is something that moves me, inspires me to think, makes me go within and interpret..so what if it takes a few dozen trips to the dictionary too!!!
It should hold my spirit, enthrall my mind, thrill me like a roller coaster! It should make me smile, cry..get angry with the society. Or just plain make me clutch my tummy and laugh till i pee my pants!!
Chetan Bhagat has commercialised the Indian literary scene. He sells "masala"...much like the flicks that come and go in Bollywood which the majority see with pants wetting enthusiasm (:S)
To tell you the truth i read the first one with much curiosity (yeah my frends luurved it!!)..the second one with a bit of trepedition ..the third one ..i didn't even bother with.
Well i have nothing personal against the guy..i seriously love him. But as most endings go..
"It's not you(Chetan)..it's meeee"
@sucheta: Ya, exactly. At the end whatever works for most people will always sell, doesn't matter whether it falls into the norms of what we call "literature" or not.
@tarushi:
LOL
I agree. Literature as we understand it is beyond the trivial parameters that you mention but then again whats good for the goose is not good for the gander! :P
Oh, how well sometimes the conjectures prove themselves automatically (to be true hypothesis :P.)
Post a Comment